The Dornier bomber crash at Castle Farm
Geoff Nutkins, owner/curator of the Shoreham Aircraft Museum, tells the story.....
Just after 10am on the 15th September 1940, nineteen Dornier 17s of III/KG 76 took off from their airfield at Cormeilles-En-Vexin, near Paris. Once the Dorniers had formed up, they headed northwest towards London, to take part in what would be the fifth daylight bombing raid on the capital. The target was to be the maze of railway lines between the Thames and Clapham Common.
Amongst the III Gruppe Dorniers was Werk Nr 2555, F1+FS, of the 8th Staffel, flown by Fw Rolf Heitsch. With him were Fw Stefan Schmid, Fw Hans Pfeiffer, and Fw Martin Sauter. Also on board was a new ‘secret weapon’. An infantry flamethrower had been fitted to the Dornier’s fuselage, facing rearwards. Any RAF fighter attacking from close behind was going to be assured of a warm reception, or so it was intended. Controlled by the radio operator, Fw Schmid, the new weapon would see action for the first time. If it didn’t set the attackers on fire, it might at least deter them from getting too close. Should it prove successful, the weapon would be introduced on other bombers.
The Dorniers reached the outskirts of London without loss. The escorting fighters, and the advance guard of fighters ‘free hunting’ ahead, had done their job well. In the rear of the formation was Werk Nr 2555, it’s secret weapon as yet unused. In his book ‘Battle of Britain Day’, Alfred Price tells how Fw Schmid reported a British fighter closing in from behind. Sgt Ray Holmes, in his 504 Sqdn Hurricane, closed in to 400 yards before opening fire. As he did so, his windscreen was suddenly coated in black oil, which completely blocked his view.
The flamethrower, obviously intended for use on the ground, was not working properly at 16,000 feet, giving a jet of flame only some 100 yards long. A lot of the oil had not caught fire, and it was this that had found its way onto the Hurricane. Knowing that the airflow would clear the oil away, Ray Holmes waited for his view to be restored. As his windscreen cleared, Ray realised that he was dangerously close to the Dornier, and ramming the stick forward, passed beneath the bomber.
If Ray Holmes had escaped the clutches of the secret weapon without damage, the same could not be said of the Dornier. The starboard engine had been hit by machine gun fire, forcing Heitsch to feather the propeller and leaving him to struggle with the controls.
With one engine out, Heitsch was forced to drop out of the bomber formation. Below was a bank of cloud, and he headed the Dornier towards it, knowing that it would shield him from enemy fighters. Before they could reach the enveloping cloud, they came under attack from several RAF fighters. Each time one approached, the flamethrower was triggered, but perversely it seemed to have the wrong effect!
To the RAF pilots, the jet of flame and smoke made the Dornier look as if it was on fire, and sensing an easy victory they went in to attack! Several pilots reported attacking the Dornier. Sgt Robinson, of 257 Sqdn reported that the Dornier ‘caught fire in the rear’, Pilot Officer Campbell, of 242 Sqdn, stated that ‘When I opened fire, smoke was observed issuing from the lower part of the fuselage of the enemy aircraft’, whilst Sgt Suidak, of 302 Sqdn noted ‘Black smoke pouring from the cockpit’. He also reported that as another pilot attacked, the Dornier caught fire BEFORE the pilot fired on it. Price says that no other Dornier caught fire in such fashion, and that the pilots must have been referring to Werk Nr 2555.
Eventually, the flamethrower’s operator, Fw Schmid was hit by machine gun fire, and severely wounded, which put an end to its use. More bullets hit the Dornier, and Rolf Heitsch realised that the other engine was starting to lose power.
It was obvious that all hope of reaching France had gone. With the radio operator badly wounded, there was no question of bailing out, and leaving him behind, a forced landing was the only option. Price reports that the British fighters, seeing that the Dornier was going down, followed it without attacking. He credits the demise of the Dornier to Sgt Holmes (504 Sqdn), P/O Lawson (19 Sqdn), P/O Crossman (46 Sqdn), and P/O Mortimer (257 Sqdn).
However, the books ‘The Battle of Britain, Then and Now’, and ‘The Blitz, Then and Now’ which are widely accepted as having the most accurate listings of who shot down who, state that Werk Nr 2555, having been damaged by fighters and AA fire, was finished off by F/O J.C. Dundas, and P/O E.Q. Tobin, both of 609 Sqdn!
During the research for ‘Battle of Britain Day’ Alfred Price met and interviewed Rolf Heitsch, so even if there may be some doubt over who shot the Dornier down, the rest of his account must be regarded as reliable. Perhaps the two sources can be reconciled, and we can say that in evaluating the combat reports filed by pilots that day, they differed over the involvement of Dundas and Tobin, and that the pilots mentioned by Price were the pilots of the fighters that had damaged the Dornier before Dundas and Tobin attacked it.
In any event, the end result was the same. Just after mid-day, the Dornier came to rest, undercarriage up, on the brow of a field above Castle Farm, on the outskirts of Shoreham, Kent, narrowly missing the high-tension cables that ran over the field. Having released the escape hatch, the crew of the Dornier carefully brought the unconscious Stefan Schmid out of the cockpit, and laid him on the grass. The radio operator was badly wounded in the chest, and Rolf Heitsch, who had trained as a doctor before the war, could see that there was nothing that could be done to save him. Fw Martin Sauter, and the observer, Fw Pfeiffer had also been wounded, but less seriously. Schmid was taken to Sevenoaks Hospital, but was found to be dead on arrival.
Not surprisingly, as this incident occurred in our own backyard, the museum has long had an interest in these events. Several local people have been traced who remember that day. Jack Marriot, an ARP Warden recalls the incident: ‘We ran across a field to where a German Dornier 'Flying Pencil' lay on the ground with little damage except for a smashed undercarriage. Three of the crew who were not seriously injured had been taken away by the Home Guard. One was lying beside the aircraft. The First Aid crew applied dressings and bandages to the bullet wounds in his chest. We carried him to the ambulance, this was the first German I had seen close up. He was very young and ghostly pale, his uniform looked shabby and he had holes in his flying boots, not at all the ruthless superman type we had been led to expect. Colonel Greenwood and his Home Guard collected one of the uninjured airmen. He told me afterwards “the poor blighter seemed very shaken so the boys and I stopped off at the Crown* and I bought him a pint* before we turned him in".
[*See footnote at bottom of page].
Amongst the III Gruppe Dorniers was Werk Nr 2555, F1+FS, of the 8th Staffel, flown by Fw Rolf Heitsch. With him were Fw Stefan Schmid, Fw Hans Pfeiffer, and Fw Martin Sauter. Also on board was a new ‘secret weapon’. An infantry flamethrower had been fitted to the Dornier’s fuselage, facing rearwards. Any RAF fighter attacking from close behind was going to be assured of a warm reception, or so it was intended. Controlled by the radio operator, Fw Schmid, the new weapon would see action for the first time. If it didn’t set the attackers on fire, it might at least deter them from getting too close. Should it prove successful, the weapon would be introduced on other bombers.
The Dorniers reached the outskirts of London without loss. The escorting fighters, and the advance guard of fighters ‘free hunting’ ahead, had done their job well. In the rear of the formation was Werk Nr 2555, it’s secret weapon as yet unused. In his book ‘Battle of Britain Day’, Alfred Price tells how Fw Schmid reported a British fighter closing in from behind. Sgt Ray Holmes, in his 504 Sqdn Hurricane, closed in to 400 yards before opening fire. As he did so, his windscreen was suddenly coated in black oil, which completely blocked his view.
The flamethrower, obviously intended for use on the ground, was not working properly at 16,000 feet, giving a jet of flame only some 100 yards long. A lot of the oil had not caught fire, and it was this that had found its way onto the Hurricane. Knowing that the airflow would clear the oil away, Ray Holmes waited for his view to be restored. As his windscreen cleared, Ray realised that he was dangerously close to the Dornier, and ramming the stick forward, passed beneath the bomber.
If Ray Holmes had escaped the clutches of the secret weapon without damage, the same could not be said of the Dornier. The starboard engine had been hit by machine gun fire, forcing Heitsch to feather the propeller and leaving him to struggle with the controls.
With one engine out, Heitsch was forced to drop out of the bomber formation. Below was a bank of cloud, and he headed the Dornier towards it, knowing that it would shield him from enemy fighters. Before they could reach the enveloping cloud, they came under attack from several RAF fighters. Each time one approached, the flamethrower was triggered, but perversely it seemed to have the wrong effect!
To the RAF pilots, the jet of flame and smoke made the Dornier look as if it was on fire, and sensing an easy victory they went in to attack! Several pilots reported attacking the Dornier. Sgt Robinson, of 257 Sqdn reported that the Dornier ‘caught fire in the rear’, Pilot Officer Campbell, of 242 Sqdn, stated that ‘When I opened fire, smoke was observed issuing from the lower part of the fuselage of the enemy aircraft’, whilst Sgt Suidak, of 302 Sqdn noted ‘Black smoke pouring from the cockpit’. He also reported that as another pilot attacked, the Dornier caught fire BEFORE the pilot fired on it. Price says that no other Dornier caught fire in such fashion, and that the pilots must have been referring to Werk Nr 2555.
Eventually, the flamethrower’s operator, Fw Schmid was hit by machine gun fire, and severely wounded, which put an end to its use. More bullets hit the Dornier, and Rolf Heitsch realised that the other engine was starting to lose power.
It was obvious that all hope of reaching France had gone. With the radio operator badly wounded, there was no question of bailing out, and leaving him behind, a forced landing was the only option. Price reports that the British fighters, seeing that the Dornier was going down, followed it without attacking. He credits the demise of the Dornier to Sgt Holmes (504 Sqdn), P/O Lawson (19 Sqdn), P/O Crossman (46 Sqdn), and P/O Mortimer (257 Sqdn).
However, the books ‘The Battle of Britain, Then and Now’, and ‘The Blitz, Then and Now’ which are widely accepted as having the most accurate listings of who shot down who, state that Werk Nr 2555, having been damaged by fighters and AA fire, was finished off by F/O J.C. Dundas, and P/O E.Q. Tobin, both of 609 Sqdn!
During the research for ‘Battle of Britain Day’ Alfred Price met and interviewed Rolf Heitsch, so even if there may be some doubt over who shot the Dornier down, the rest of his account must be regarded as reliable. Perhaps the two sources can be reconciled, and we can say that in evaluating the combat reports filed by pilots that day, they differed over the involvement of Dundas and Tobin, and that the pilots mentioned by Price were the pilots of the fighters that had damaged the Dornier before Dundas and Tobin attacked it.
In any event, the end result was the same. Just after mid-day, the Dornier came to rest, undercarriage up, on the brow of a field above Castle Farm, on the outskirts of Shoreham, Kent, narrowly missing the high-tension cables that ran over the field. Having released the escape hatch, the crew of the Dornier carefully brought the unconscious Stefan Schmid out of the cockpit, and laid him on the grass. The radio operator was badly wounded in the chest, and Rolf Heitsch, who had trained as a doctor before the war, could see that there was nothing that could be done to save him. Fw Martin Sauter, and the observer, Fw Pfeiffer had also been wounded, but less seriously. Schmid was taken to Sevenoaks Hospital, but was found to be dead on arrival.
Not surprisingly, as this incident occurred in our own backyard, the museum has long had an interest in these events. Several local people have been traced who remember that day. Jack Marriot, an ARP Warden recalls the incident: ‘We ran across a field to where a German Dornier 'Flying Pencil' lay on the ground with little damage except for a smashed undercarriage. Three of the crew who were not seriously injured had been taken away by the Home Guard. One was lying beside the aircraft. The First Aid crew applied dressings and bandages to the bullet wounds in his chest. We carried him to the ambulance, this was the first German I had seen close up. He was very young and ghostly pale, his uniform looked shabby and he had holes in his flying boots, not at all the ruthless superman type we had been led to expect. Colonel Greenwood and his Home Guard collected one of the uninjured airmen. He told me afterwards “the poor blighter seemed very shaken so the boys and I stopped off at the Crown* and I bought him a pint* before we turned him in".
[*See footnote at bottom of page].
Someone else who, in 1982, well remembered that day was Reg Hewitt; ‘I can remember the day of the crash vividly. I was a young boy of about fourteen living at 1 Castle Farm Cottages. My mother and I were in the back garden near the shed when a man who had walked along the footpath from Shoreham came down the road by the cottage and shouted “Look out madam, there’s a plane coming down”. We saw nothing of the plane but my mother and I rushed indoors and heard a plane fly past very low to the Eynsford side of the house. As soon as it had gone I ran outside and, with the man and a neighbour, ran up the bank opposite intending to run across the field and up the hill to where we could see that the plane had crashed. Almost immediately one of our own fighters circled overhead. It had its canopy open and the pilot waved a handkerchief at us apparently signalling for us to go back. We returned to our cottages. Within a few minutes we went up the back again and then we could see that many people had arrived and were in the field where the plane was.
After the crew had been taken away everyone dispersed and the army, which at that time was stationed at Lullingstone Castle, put a guard on the plane, and then they had a tent pitched under some trees where they kept watch day and night. Those of us who worked on the farm were not allowed to go near it. There was even talk that they thought the Germans might come and bomb the wreck.
I spoke to Mr Eric Watts, a man now in his seventies [1982]. He lived and worked on the farm at the time, and he told me that he remembered that Sunday morning and that his neighbour, Mr Sid Dines, was sitting outside reading the newspaper, and that he waved his paper to the German aircraft not knowing that it was an enemy plane.
There is no truth in the story that the Germans deliberately fired on hop-pickers at Castle Farm. A man was hit in the leg, but this was due to our own fighters firing at the German plane and forcing it down.
The plane lay in the field for two or three weeks and then was taken away in three separate lorry loads. Two engines went on one lorry, the fuselage was on another and the wings on the third. These went away as they dismantled the plane in separate loads spaced over several days. I found the undercarriage indicator gauge and recently [1982] donated it to the Shoreham Aircraft Museum, along with the forage cap belonging to one of the crew. These are the only surviving relics from the incident’.
The Castle Farm Dornier turned up at Lowestoft in late October 1940, when it was exhibited on the Crown Meadow in aid of the local Spitfire fund, sixpence to view.
The Castle Farm Dornier turned up at Lowestoft in late October 1940, when it was exhibited on the Crown Meadow in aid of the local Spitfire fund, sixpence to view.
In 1982, Martin Sauter’s daughter Martina, visited our museum,
and was taken to see the field where her father’s aircraft had
come down.
The Shoreham Aircraft Museum has a display dedicated to the incident including
a diorama of the crash-site, a copy of the combat report submitted by F/O Dundas,
the forage cap and undercarriage position indicator donated by Reg Hewitt, photographs of the crew, photographs of Martina and from the occasion when
Martin Sauter and Hans Pfeiffer had a reunion in Germany in 1984.
The museum owner/curator, Geoff Nutkins, also happens to be a very talented artist. The Shoreham Dornier has been immortalised in two paintings, the 'Height of the Battle' depicts the Dornier being chased down the Darent Valley by the Spitfires of Dundas and Tobin, and ‘The Castle Farm Dornier’, depicts the scene after the forced-landing. Prints are available from Geoff's Aviation Art website.
* There's no doubt the rather shaken-up but uninjured airman was taken to a pub and given a drink. Accounts differ on the details though - some say he was taken to the Crown, some say the George, some say he was bought a pint, some say a brandy. Probably a case of Chinese whispers, I doubt we'll ever know for sure.... unless you know different? Please do tell.